Why I Fear the New Curriculum for Wales – A Parent’s Perspective
Katherine Gibson • 22 June 2025

Why I Fear The New Curriculum For Wales

The New Curriculum for Wales aims to give schools more flexibility, promote creativity, and better prepare students for life beyond the classroom. But while the policy is filled with good intentions, not every parent feels confident in its implementation.


In this article, I want to share the growing fears I carry as both a Welsh parent and a Science teacher of 20 years. I’m deeply worried about slipping educational standards, inconsistent teaching across schools, and the unknown long-term impact on our children’s futures. This isn’t just policy on paper — it’s their lives, their opportunities, and their sense of security that feel at stake.


As a parent of two children—one aged 14 and the other 12—I find myself standing at a curious crossroads in Welsh education. My son, currently 14, will be sitting the majority of his GCSEs under the “old” system. My daughter, however, will be part of the first full wave of students learning and being assessed under the new Curriculum for Wales. And honestly? I’m worried.


To say I’m thankful that my son will complete the traditional GCSEs is an understatement. He’s a highly motivated young man with a clear goal: he wants to join the Royal Navy. He knows what he needs to do, and the road ahead is signposted with well-established milestones. His qualifications will align closely with those across the border in England. When he applies for university—or anything else, for that matter—his grades will be instantly understood and respected. There’s comfort in that clarity.


But then there’s my daughter.


She’s only just starting her journey in secondary education, and already, I’m anxious about what lies ahead. The new Curriculum for Wales sounds impressive on paper. It promises flexibility, creativity, learner-centred progress, and freedom from the pressure of “teaching to the test.” In principle, it’s exactly the kind of approach we dream of for our children. But in practice? I fear it may be a very different story.


A “freer” curriculum only works well when the assessments match the teaching. That model can flourish when individual schools set their own exams based on what they’ve actually delivered. But we’re not living in that world. We still have external qualifications. The mantra may be “don’t teach to the test,” but as soon as you introduce national assessment criteria, schools must align with them. And let’s be honest—if we’re assessing, there’s always a test of some kind.


How Will the New Curriculum for Wales Affect Our Children’s Futures?

 

My biggest concern? I don’t know what qualifications my daughter will ultimately walk away with. As a Science teacher of two decades, I’ve seen firsthand the value of teaching Biology, Chemistry, and Physics as separate disciplines. Will she instead study a single, merged “Science” qualification under this new system? And if so, will that dilute the depth of knowledge she needs—especially if she chooses a science-based university course later?


I can’t help but wonder if she’ll be disadvantaged compared to students in England or Northern Ireland, where more traditional routes remain intact. Will she be left trying to catch up in a competitive world that still values subject-specific expertise?


Are we watering things down too much? Giving too much freedom without the structure needed to ensure equity across the UK?


I don’t have the answers.


But I do know what parents like me are hoping for.


What Parents Really Want from the New Curriculum for Wales


Parents want a curriculum that:

  • Ensures consistency across schools
  • Prioritises subject depth as well as creativity
  • Supports all learners, including those with additional needs
  • Provides clear, measurable outcomes
  • Allows meaningful parental involvement
     

These aren’t radical demands. They’re common-sense expectations from those of us trying to support our children through a time of massive educational change. It’s worth remembering that Scotland took a very similar approach when they launched Curriculum for Excellence. In the end, they had to row back—because it just didn’t work the way they’d hoped. That’s not to say Wales will do the same, but I can’t ignore the warning signs.


I do have a choice. Working in the world of Home Education, I know I could step in. I could ensure she follows a more traditional pathway—structured GCSEs, clear specifications, the same qualifications as her brother. It would give her the same playing field. Is that the route I want to take?


Right now, I don’t know. But I’m watching closely.


You can find more information in the Welsh Government website Hwb.


You can also download “A guide to the new Curriculum for Wales” here.


Have thoughts or experiences with the New Curriculum for Wales?  Join the conversation below or share your story — your voice matters.

Share

A person holding a lens overlooking the horizon
by Kate Gibson 23 October 2025
When it comes to our children, few decisions feel as heavy as the one about whether to seek a diagnosis. As parents, we just want to do what’s best, to nurture, protect, and understand our child in every possible way. But when questions arise about learning, attention, behaviour, or emotional wellbeing, the path forward can suddenly feel uncertain. Recently, Gav and I found ourselves standing at this very crossroads with our own daughter. We began to notice differences, little things that didn’t quite fit the pattern of what we’d expected. Some days, we felt sure we were overthinking. Other days, we couldn’t shake the feeling that perhaps there was something more going on beneath the surface. That’s when we came across the phrase that has stayed with me ever since: “Not a label, but a lens.” Those five words changed how we viewed the entire conversation about testing, diagnosis, and support. The Case for Testing: Seeing Through a New Lens A diagnosis can offer clarity not as a verdict, but as understanding. It can shine light into areas that have long felt confusing or frustrating. It gives parents, teachers, and the child themselves a shared language to talk about what’s happening and how to help. For some families, a diagnosis opens doors to support that might otherwise be closed such aa access to resources, tailored strategies, and compassionate professionals who can make a real difference. For the child, it can be empowering. When a child understands why something feels difficult or why they think, learn, or respond differently it can ease shame and build self-awareness. Instead of asking, “What’s wrong with me?”, they can begin to ask, “What do I need?” That’s the beauty of the lens. It helps us see not just the challenges, but the strengths that come with difference. The Case for Waiting: The Power of Knowing the Child First But the other side of the conversation is just as important. A diagnosis can be helpful, yes, but it is not always necessary. Sometimes, in our urgency to find answers, we risk narrowing our view too soon. A label, if treated carelessly, can unintentionally define a child rather than describe them. It can shape expectations, both our own and others’, before we’ve truly taken the time to understand who that child is. Every child deserves to be seen and supported as an individual first. Testing should never replace connection, patience, and curiosity. In some cases, the best approach is to continue observing, adapting, and working collaboratively between parents, educators, and the child themselves without the pressure of a formal label. Standing at the Crossroads And so, that’s where we found ourselves somewhere in between. Wanting to know more, yet not wanting our daughter to be reduced to a word or category. In the end, what helped us most was reframing the question. Instead of asking, “Should we test or not?”, we asked, “What do we hope to understand?” When we began to see the process as a tool for insight, not an endpoint or a judgment, the decision became gentler. Whether we went ahead with testing or not, we knew our goal was the same: to work with our daughter, not on her. Not a Label, but a Lens Every child is unique. Some thrive when we have the language that a diagnosis provides; others simply need time, support, and empathy to grow in their own way. A label, in itself, changes nothing. What matters is how we use it, whether we choose to see it as a lens that helps us look more closely, understand more deeply, and respond more compassionately. So if you’re at that same crossroads, unsure whether to test or not, know that it’s okay to sit in the uncertainty for a while. The very act of asking the question means you’re already seeing your child clearly: as a whole, complex, wonderful person who deserves to be known, supported, and celebrated exactly as they are. Get in touch: info@crossroads.wales or Contact Us — Kate , Director, Crossroads
Meinir said her daughter Mali
by Kate Gibson 13 September 2025
Crossroads featured on BBC as home schooling in Wales triples. Supporting families with wellbeing, confidence, and trusted exam options.
Boy and girl sitting in the woods
by Gavin Gibson 26 August 2025
Elective Home Education on the Rise
More posts